Aphria versus Aurora Cannabis: A Valuation Update – Market Realist

Aphria versus Aurora Cannabis: A Valuation Update - Market Realist
Aphria versus Aurora Cannabis: A Valuation Update
Therefore, Auroras stock feels the heat whenever the overall cannabis sector falls out of favor. Thats apparently what happened in August, as Auroras big decline came not after any company-specific news, but rather after the earnings reports of peers Canopy Growth (NYSE: CGC) and Tilray (NASDAQ: TLRY).

In early August, Aurora actually gave preliminary revenue numbers for the quarter ended June 30, though the company wont report official earnings until Sept. 12. Aurora expects revenue between $100 million and $107 million, compared to $19.1 million a year ago and $65.1 million in the March quarter. That was enough to please analysts, which initially pushed Auroras stock up.

However, in mid-August, Canopy Growth filed its earnings report, which missed both revenue and profit expectations by a wide margin. Tilray also delivered an earnings report that missed profit expectations, though it did beat analyst expectations for revenue. Of particular note was Tilrays reported 28% decline in average price per gram during the quarter. That may have led investors to believe that the Canadian market is oversupplied.

In August, Aurora gave investors an update on its operations in which it stated that based on preliminary and unaudited results, it expected sales for Q4 to come in between 100 million and 107 million Canadian dollars. Thats more than five times what the company generated a year ago, back when the adult-use market in Canada hadnt yet opened for business. Those are some impressive sales numbers, and they would be even higher than what rival Canopy Growth (NYSE:CGC) was able to generate in its latest results, when it posted revenues of just CA$90.5 million.

It was odd that Auroras stock declined so much with its peers after it had already given quarterly revenue numbers. Nevertheless, the whole sector has been under pressure in the second half of this year. Concerns about valuation, combined with a risk-off mentality in the markets, have weighed on all cannabis producers since the spring.

Aurora officially reports fourth-quarter and full-year earnings on Sept. 12, when management will add additional color to the revenue guidance. Of note, Aurora recently won a big overseas contract in Italy in July, and also bought hemp and CBD company Hempco Food and Fiber Inc. for 63.4 million Canadian dollars in the middle of August.

Of course, the most important thing for investors to monitor is the state of supply and demand in the Canadian market, as well as the ramp-up of Auroras industry-leading production facilities.

Billy Duberstein has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. His clients may own shares of the companies mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

Even though Aurora may be expecting a good quarter in terms of sales, some of those benefits were likely already realized in August.

Since the beginning of August, Aphria (APHA) and Aurora Cannabis (ACB) have returned 30.0% and -2.7%, respectively.

Aphria reported a strong fourth-quarter performance on August 1. For the fourth quarter, the company beat analysts top-line and bottom-line expectations. The companys net profits were 15.8 million Canadian dollars—compared to analysts expectation of a loss of 13.9 million Canadian dollars. The impressive fourth-quarter performance caused Aphrias stock price to rise. On August 22, the company announced a distribution agreement with ParcelPal Technology. According to the deal, ParcelPal will deliver Aphrias medical cannabis products to patients. The two companies have selected Calgary, Alberta, to launch their delivery service.

On August 6, Aurora Cannabiss management provided better-than-expected guidance for its fourth quarter. The company also completed its acquisition of Hempco Food and Fiber on August 19. We expect Hempcos acquisition to expand Aurora Cannabiss hemp business in the US. On September 4, Aurora Cannabis sold its stake in Green Organic Dutchman Holdings (TGOD) for 86.5 million Canadian dollars. The company earned a 50% internal rate of return by selling its Green Organic Dutchman shares. Despite all of these announcements, Aurora Cannabis stock has fallen 2.7% since July 31. Weakness in the cannabis sector led to a fall in the companys stock price. During the same period, the ETFMG Alternative Harvest ETF (MJ) and the Horizons Marijuana Life Sciences Index ETF (HMMJ) have fallen 8.4% and 6.4%, respectively. Despite the fall, Aurora Cannabis has returned 18.3% YTD, while Aphria stock has increased 18.6%.

Although Aphria stock has increased 30%, its forward EV-to-sales multiple fell from 2.53x on July 31 to 2.39x on September 6. The impressive fourth-quarter performance appears to have prompted analysts to raise their revenue expectations for the next four quarters. The higher revenue estimates lowered Aphrias forward EV-to-sales multiple. The company was trading at a lower valuation multiple compared to its forward EV-to-sales multiple of 2.76 at the beginning of this year and its historical average forward EV-to-sales multiple of 8.90x.

On September 6, Aurora Cannabis was trading at a forward EV-to-sales multiple of 11.77x compared to 12.07x on July 31. The decline of 2.7% is Aurora Cannabiss stock price led to a fall in its EV-to-sales multiple. There wasnt much change in analysts revenue expectations for the next four quarters from July 31 to September 6. However, the company is trading at a higher EV-to-sales multiple compared to 7.58x at the beginning of 2019 and its historical average of 10.48x.

In the above graph, you can see that Aurora Cannabis is trading above its peers median value of 4.74x. In contrast, Aphria is trading below its peers median value.

The better-than-expected adjusted EBITDA in the fourth quarter might have prompted analysts to raise their EBITDA estimates for the next four quarters. The increase in analysts EBITDA estimates brought Aphrias EV-to-EBITDA multiple down. As of September 6, the company was trading at a forward EV-to-EBITDA multiple of 12.86x compared to 33.24x on July 31. Currently, Aphria trades at a higher EV-to-EBITDA multiple compared to 9.58x at the beginning of this year and lower than its historical average EV-to-EBITDA multiple of 28.57x.

Analysts lowered their EBITDA estimates for Aurora Cannabis in the next four quarters compared to their estimates on July 31. The lower EBITDA estimates led to an increase in the companys valuation multiple. On September 6, the company was trading at a forward EV-to-EBITDA multiple of 58.68x compared to 49.77x on July 31. Aurora Cannabis is trading above the forward EV-to-EBITDA multiple of 26.47x at the beginning of 2019 and its historical average of 34.45x.

On September 6, Aurora Cannabis and Aphria were trading at higher forward EV-to-sales multiples than peers median value of 12.26.

Shares of T-Mobile and Sprint have been trading in a narrow range since last month. The uncertainty of their pending merger has driven their performances.

Russias regional election on Sunday produced another headache for Facebook over political ads. Facebook is already in a dispute over local data storage.

After Fridays buyout offer for Symantecs Consumer Cyber Safety segment, its stock soared 4.5% to $24.52. This pushed its market cap to $15.2 billion.

Today, Slack (WORK) stock has been getting crushed after opening marginally higher. At 12:44 PM ET, the stock was trading at $24.4, down 10.9%.

Today, the shares of AT&T gained over 9% in early market trading. It surged after hedge fund Elliott Management disclosed that it owns a $3.2 billion stake.

US steel stocks are rising today on multiple factors. Theres rising optimism over a US-China trade deal, and Chinese steel exports plummeted in August.

The Technology Select Sector ETF (XLK) has fallen 0.8% on the day. Several tech stocks are trading in the red, particularly the overvalues stocks.

Institutional holdings in Valero Energy, Marathon Petroleum, Phillips 66, and HollyFrontier stand above 70%. HollyFrontier has the highest holding of 89%.


Posted in Aurora