Birmingham Pub bombings: Victims were unlawfully killed – BBC News

Birmingham Pub bombings: Victims were unlawfully killed - BBC News
Birmingham pub bombings: victims relatives call for justice after inquest verdict
The plea – directed at police forces in Britain and Ireland – was made at the end of a six-week hearing that resulted in a jury on Friday ruling that a botched warning call in advance of the attacks caused or contributed to the deaths.

Seizing on the evidence of a convicted IRA bomber, who named four men as being responsible for the attacks, relatives demanded that police launch fresh criminal investigations and charge living suspects with what was now officially known as murder.

She added: "Whilst the police officers of the day cant be questioned in any great detail there is no way that the people of this country and the people of our community of Birmingham and our families, will allow the senior police officers to get off with letting these murderers, two of whom are still alive, get away with their continued liberty."

Julie Hambleton, who has recalled how her world fell apart aged 11 when her 18-year-old sister Maxine was killed, said: West Midlands police have always told us that when they have new evidence they will act on it. Well here you go, and Im sure there is more to be found when those perpetrators who are are still at large are caught.

Addressing the decision which outraged families, Mr Thornton said: There is no question of seeking to identify the perpetrators of the bombings – that is a task for the criminal investigation by the police and prosecution through the criminal courts.

Birmingham pub bombings inquest: Relatives call for fresh investigation as jury concludes 21 victims were murdered by the IRA

Flanked by other bereaved relatives, Hambleton said the ball is now in the court of Dave Thompson, the chief constable of West Midlands police, the Garda Síochána in Ireland and the PSNI in Northern Ireland to pursue suspects who were still living.

He added: "We just hope, in light of the jurys unequivocal finding that the IRA murdered 21 innocent people, that the West Midlands Police will now redouble their efforts in terms of those bombers who may still be alive to bring them to justice."

She added: Twenty-one of our loved ones went out one evening to meet friends and family and they never saw the light of day again. Today, the inquest has found they were unlawfully killed by murder. Whilst the police officers of the day cant be questioned in any great detail, there is no way that the people who this country and the people of our community of Birmingham and families will allow the senior police officers to get off with letting these murderers … to get away with their continued liberty.

As well as the 21 deaths, more than 200 people were injured when bombs were detonated in two city centre pubs – the Mulberry Bush and the Tavern in the Town – on the evening of 21 November 1974.

Six men who became known as the Birmingham Six were convicted in 1975 of carrying out the bombings, but were acquitted 16 years later.

Fresh inquests into the deaths were ordered in 2016, but were delayed by disputes over whether the hearings should examine who might have been responsible for the bombings. In July last year, the court of appeal decided they should not.

In a verdict read out at Birmingham civil justice centre, the 11-person jury said the deaths were not the result of police errors or omissions and that the victims had been unlawfully killed, a finding directed by the coroner, Sir Peter Thornton QC.

Maxine, known as Maccie, was described as very intelligent, clever and arty by her brother Brian. She would have been the first in our family to have gone to university. But the sad thing is, she died without ever knowing that she had won a place into university, said her sister Julie. On the night of her death, Maxine had gone into town to distribute her handmade invitations for her housewarming party. Julie added: Maccies death left a void in our hearts, an aching emptiness we will carry in this life forever. We will never know what the future held for her.

They unanimously ruled that the inadequate warning call by the Provisional IRA cost the stretched police crucial minutes.

One of the youngest victims of the bombs and the youngest of three siblings, Jane wanted to be a nuclear physicist, said her brother, Brian, at the inquest. Jane developed some close friendships with a group of like-minded girls, who, to this day, continue to meet together on or near the anniversary on the bombings, Brian said. Jane was a loving, loyal and accomplished young woman with the world at her feet. She worked part-time in a Birmingham department store, where she met Maxine Hambleton. She was with Maxine in the Tavern in the Town on the evening of her death.

It had taken a month in the inquests before the families came close to what they had wanted – the names of the people alleged to have done it. Giving evidence via secure videolink, a convicted IRA bomber known as Witness O said the four men responsible for the bombings were Seamus McLoughlin, Michael Hayes, Mick Murray and James Gavin. They had all been previously named publicly and McLoughlin, Murray and Gavin are dead.

The inquest had heard that a bomb warning using the codeword Double X – which was designed to signal it was not a hoax – was received by the Birmingham Post newspaper at 8.11pm. The jury, which was told that police did not try to clear the area or set up a cordon following the call, found that there was no tip-off to the police.

Jurors were told that shortly after 8pm on the evening of 21 November – which was payday for many and a late shopping night – two bombs exploded in the two city centre pubs. There were about 50 people in the Mulberry Bush and 200 in the Tavern in the Town.

However, jurors heard the warning had only given the locations as the landmark Rotunda building and the nearby Tax Office in New Street, making no mention of pubs, including the Mulberry Bush where the attack happened.

The West Midlands had experienced what was described in the inquest as a serious and sustained campaign of attacks by the IRA in the preceding 12 months, with 53 bombing incidents in the year leading up to 21 November.

After sitting through almost six weeks of evidence at the inquest, the 11-member jury found a botched IRA warning call contributed to the deaths of 21 people unlawfully killed in the 1974 Birmingham pub bombings.

That night there were only 15 police officers in Birmingham city centre because 135 officers from the Digbeth and Steelhouse Lane stations had been deployed to police the funeral procession for the Provisional IRA member James McDade, who had been killed while planting a bomb at the GPO telephone exchange in Coventry the week before.

Facebook Twitter Pinterest The Birmingham Six pictured on 14 March 1991, the day their convictions were quashed. Left to right: John Walker, Paddy Hill, Hugh Callaghan, Chris Mullin MP (who campaigned for their release), Richard McIlkenny, Gerry Hunter and William Power. Photograph: Sean Dempsey/PA The bombs were detonated between 8.15pm and 8.20pm – first at the Mulberry Bush and then at the Tavern in the Town – but it was not until 9.10pm that extra police officers started arriving, after the Aer Lingus flight carrying McDades body left at 8.30pm.

In his evidence to the inquests, the then IRA head of intelligence in Ireland, Kieran Conway, described the victims' deaths as "accidental", in an "IRA operation that went badly wrong".

In a police statement from the time of the bombings that was read to the jury, Mary Jones, the wife of David Jones, the licensee of the Mulberry Bush, said she remembered chatting to a group of regulars including Stanley Bodman, John Rowlands, Michael Beasley, James Caddick and John Clifford Jones, all of whom were killed.

Speaking in March during at the inquest into the deaths, an ex-IRA volunteer, known as Witness O, said the IRA had granted permission for Hayes and three other men, who are all dead, to be named as suspects in the attack.

Survivors described crawling over bodies to escape the wreckage of the two pubs. Paul Murphy, who was 17 and in the Tavern in the Town drinking with friends, said one of his first thoughts after the blast was that his father was going to kill him for being in a pub. He suffered 33% burns and all of the muscles in his right arm were lacerated.

The blast had blown most of your clothes off. No hair, no eyebrows, your private parts are covered, because youre wearing three layers, he said. Your socks were blown off to the level of your shoes. Youve lost that much blood, its like when you step in a river, youre squelching in your own blood.

Michael Hayes, who was named by an anonymous ex-IRA volunteer giving evidence at the inquests, said nobody was meant to die in what he described as a "commercial bombing campaign".

A report from a team at the Centre for Blast Injury Studies (CBIS), which was read to the court, heard that the injuries suffered by the 19 victims who died on the night were unsurvivable, even with current advanced medical treatment. Thomas Chaytor and James Craig died later in hospital, but the inquest was told it was likely they would have died in any circumstances.

Julie Hambleton, who lost her older sister in the bombings, said prior to the hearing the families of the deceased wanted "truth, justice and accountability".

Speaking via videolink from Dublin, the former IRA intelligence chief Kieran Conway denied that the attacks constituted murder and instead described them as an IRA operation gone wrong.

IRA chiefs were told the atrocity was down to the delay in calling in the coded warning because the chosen phone box was out of order, said Conway, a criminal defence solicitor in Ireland who was convicted of handling explosives in Derry in the 1970s. Asked if this could have been a well-orchestrated and convenient lie so the bombing team could avoid punishment, he agreed that it could have been.

Giving evidence a few days later, the former MP Chris Mullin, whose investigative journalism was vital in the freeing of the Birmingham Six, refused to give the names of the people he thought had carried out the attack and were still alive. He said they had only spoken to him on condition that he protect their identity.

His evidence produced a furious reaction from the family of Maxine Hambleton, who was killed in the bombing aged 18, with her sister shouting across the court room that Mullin was a disgrace. Mullin had to be escorted from the building following his evidence by police and security guards as members of the Hambleton family jostled him and shouted that he had done nothing for the victims who were slaughtered in cold blood.

Twenty-one people were killed in the bombings of the Mulberry Bush and the Tavern in the Town pubs in November 1974


Posted in Birmingham